- J. T. Montgomery (October 1918 - November 1919)
- Norman G. Kittrell (December 1919 - October 1921)
- R. H. Hamilton (October 1921 - February 1921)
- Hugh B. Short (February 1925 - September 1934)
- W. M. Taylor (February 1935 - September 1945)
- S. P. Sadler (October 1918 - November 1920)
- Ben H. Powell (November 1920 - October 1927)
- Charles A. Leddy (November 1927 - September 1933)
- Graham B. Smedley (September 1933 - September 1945)
- James W. McClendon (October 1918 - December 1923)
- Robert W. Stayton (December 1923 - June 1925)
- Ocie Speer (June 1925 - October 1929)
- Joseph Ryan (October 1929 - February 1937)
- A. B. Martin (March 1937 - December 1939)
- Charles S. Slatton (January 1949 - September 1945)
When the 1945 constitutional amendment increased the number of members of the Court from three to nine, Commissioners Brewster, Folley, Hickman, Taylor, Smedley, and Slatton became justices, and the Commission of Appeals was abolished.